Document Type : Original Article


Allameh Tabataba’i University, Tehran, Iran


Purpose: The present paper aims at identifying and extracting the dimensions, components, and criteria of digital library evaluation based on experts` opinions and the 5S conceptual framework of Goncalves.Methodology: This was an applied, documentary, and survey research making the best use of the fuzzy Delphi method (to extract criteria and develop the conceptual model), forming a trinity in methodology. To refine the components, and criteria, 20 Iranian and foreign experts were polled about digital libraries in 3 stages. The results of each stage were refined based on Minkowski formula. This was an applied research since it presented the evaluation criteria of Iranian digital libraries, and its results can be practically used, enabling digital libraries to evaluate and examine their status quo, and accordingly plan and enhance their activities. It was a descriptive study based on the research design and data collection method. To gather the data, three methods were used: documentary study, fuzzy Delphi (to extract criteria and develop the conceptual model), and survey, creating a trinity in methodology. Findings: During the three stages of the experts` poll, in Stream component 4 criteria, Structure component 4, Space component 4, Scenario component 5 and in societies component 3 ones were refined and also the results of each stage were refined using the formulas of Cheng and Lin model and ultimately the experts agreed with each other on 20 criteria.
Conclusion: A digital library evaluation model was designed with 5 dimensions (components), 20 criteria, and 50 sub-criteria. It was offered to all organizations and universities as an evaluation model for digital library performance examination, so that they properly perceive the efficiency and effectiveness of digital libraries and their services.


Cheng, Ching-Hsue & Lin, Yin. (2002) "Evaluating the best mail battle tank using fuzzy decision theory with linguistic criteria evaluation", European Journal of Operational Research, vol.142, p.147
Fox, E. A, Gonçalves,M.A. Shen,R. (2012). Theoretical Foundations for Digital Libraries: The 5S (Societies, Scenarios, Spaces, Structures, Streams) Approach. Synthesis Lectures on Information Concepts, Retrieval, and Services, 4 (2):1-180.
Fax, E.A;Goncalves, M.A (2009). 5S Framework for digital libraries: introduction.Retrieved 4 September 2018, from
Gonçcalves, M.A.) 2004 (. Streams, structures, spaces, scenarios, and societies (5s): a formal digital library framework and its applications. Retrieved 5 September from
Gonçalves, M.A. Moreira, B.L. Fox, E.A. Watson, L.T. (2007). "What is a good digital library?–A quality model for digital libraries". Information processing & management, 43 (5):1416-1437.
Mokhtary Asky,Hamid Reza;Alidousty,Sirus (2013) "A revision of digital library concept;Analysis of information site of Iran.doc using the 5S official model". A collection of articles of digital library national Conference. A decade of digital libraries in Iran with a glimpse of future,edited by Mehdy Alipour Hafezy; Research center of sciences and technology of Iran`s information.
Murty, Uma and (2007). Extending the 5S Digital Library (DL) Framework: From a Minimal DL towards a DL Reference Model. Retrieved 12 June,2018 from:
Randhawa,J.S and Ahuja,L.S (2017). 5S – a quality improvement tool for sustainable performance: literature review and directions".International Journal of Quality & Reliability management,34 (3):334-361;
 Samiee, Mitra (2016). Analysis of Delos reference model and 5S framework on organization and evaluation of digital libraries; Quartely of knowledge studies,6 (2)80-100.
Shen Rao, Goncalves, Andre Fax, Edward Allan.translated by Mehdy Alipur Hafezy & al (2015). Crucial issues of digital libraries.Tehran; Fatemy. Asatyr Parsy
Syaddaty,Leila (2016). Analysis of digi qual model based on the theoretical framework of 5S in digital libraries (MA dissertation) the faculty of psychology and educational sciences, Allame tabatab’i University,Tehran.